About The Cave

The Cave is the Sarasota area’s premier destination for trading cards, comics, and sports collectibles. Founded by Brenden Kelly, The Cave was built for collectors, by a collector — a place where the hobby comes first and every customer feels at home.

Whether you’re a seasoned collector hunting for graded gems or just getting started, we’ve got something for everyone. From PSA-graded sports cards and sealed hobby boxes to jerseys, figurines, and pop culture memorabilia — our shelves are packed with treasures waiting to be discovered.

With two locations in Sarasota and Nokomis, there’s always a Cave nearby. Stop in, browse the collection, and become part of our growing community of collectors.